Doomed by Markets and Chance
By Alan Dove
A few weeks ago, I read an interesting essay on Reactor about speculative fiction books that flopped, through no fault of the author or story. That led me to a blog post by Becky Allen, whose 2016-17 fantasy duology “never found [its] audience.” Allen’s post is a gold mine for anyone interested in the publishing industry in particular, or survivorship bias in general.
We hear all about successful authors (and entrepreneurs, and performing artists, and so on), because renown is a natural byproduct of success. In our celebrity-obsessed culture, renown also makes the next success a lot more likely, so once someone gets that cycle going, they often continue to rise. That feeds the dominant narrative of success: some people have a combination of innate talent, dedication, and a solid work ethic that guarantees they’ll do well.
There’s a glaring flaw in that story. If we only look at the successes, we miss all the talented, dedicated, hardworking people who tried all the same things, but didn’t make it. They are legion. Unfortunately, because of our strong bias against discussing failure, those stories seldom get told.
After reading Allen’s post, I picked up the books and started reading, to see what failed novels look like. Both volumes, Bound by Blood and Sand and Freed by Flame and Storm, are now available as DRM-free Ebooks.
In Bound by Blood and Sand, we meet Jae, cursed from birth to be a slave in a drought-stricken desert world. A magical Well provides the only water in this place, but it’s drying up, and unless someone can find a way to fix it, everyone is doomed. Elan, a son of one of the ruling families, comes to the remote estate where Jae works, hoping to learn more about the Well. When Jae discovers she’s the only one who can wield the ancient magic needed to restore the flow of water, Elan’s tyrannical father tries to control her to preserve the world he rules. But why would a slave save a world she loathes, when she could just as easily watch it burn?
While the first book doesn’t end on a cliffhanger, it does leave some major issues in the overarching conflict unresolved, setting up the second volume, Freed by Flame and Storm. By now, Elan has been disavowed by his father, cast out of the life he’d known for throwing in his lot with Jae. The two of them, aided by a growing group of resistance fighters, make their way to the capital to free all of the other slaves and bring down the ruling order. Now it’s Jae who must confront the ethics of her own power and decide how to use it. She knows she should bring about peace, but deep down, she also wants revenge.
If you’ve read much fantasy fiction, especially the young adult kind, that summary probably gave you a pretty good sense of all of the major plot points. I found the worldbuilding solid and the character arcs well developed. The emotional beats landed well, and even though there weren’t any major surprises, the duology was a fast, enjoyable read. I especially liked Allen’s deft handling of the themes of power, privilege, and propaganda: perennial concepts in these sorts of books, but they never go out of style.
Don’t you hate it when something perfectly good gets thrown away?
Based on these examples, I’d say failed novels look pretty much like successful ones. These books are as good as anything else on the YA shelves. So why did they flop? Allen’s post goes into some of the possible issues, ranging from limited marketing by the publisher to a mismatch with genre expectations (what, no romance?) but I’d like to point out one more: luck.
Traditional publishers release thousands of books a year now, and the enormous boom in self-publishing in the past couple of decades added millions more to that annual flow, even before the tsunami of AI slop arrived. At the same time, so many other forms of entertainment now claw for our attention that fewer of us are reading fiction. With a supply glut and a demand drought, only a handful of books will ever become big sellers; the rest will be considered failures.
It’s like an inverse of the classic Swiss cheese model of accidents. In publishing, all the holes have to line up perfectly for a book to succeed. Worse, having a debut novel that doesn’t sell as well as the publisher expected makes it even less likely that the odds will be in their favor for the next one, if there is a next one. The stigma of an established record of poor sales will haunt an author forever.
Despite that bleak outlook, Allen manages to end on a positive note. Yes, her books were deemed failures. But, as she points out, most people never even manage to write one.